JFK RFK MLK Assasination Forum - Archive

ThomZajac wrote:Perhaps we can find out the origin of the photo Jesus used. More importantly, I don't see how the photo matters all that much anyway; No one disputes the size of the original wound.Touche' another great point Tom!Steve

tom jeffers wrote:if he used a retouched photo, he should have announced it rather than trying to pass it off as an original. it only decreases his credibility even if he is correct in his philosophy.I was thinking the exact same thing, I was going to try and google him to see if he could be asked w...

Hey Joe,Regardless of the photo Jesus shows, I didn't for one second think his thesis was based on the photo...I noticed it but didn't give it any weight in my thought process at all. To be honest, I recall thinking he perhaps touched it up himself just to demonstrate what it must have looked like h...

Lofty's comments quoted right below:I have thought long and hard about the throat shot, and i have to say that i dont concur with the throat shot theory because,Kennedy's hands were up in front of his throat but clenched, indicating a trauma to the muscles /nerves in the mid upper back.He could not ...

I hate to sound like someone with a one track mind but I guess it is unavoidable. I'm mainly interested in objective feedback about the proposed theory of Gil and the few additional ideas I added to it? If Gil Jesus (or myself) is wrong, so be it, but lets debate the evidence that proves it? I've re...

Bob wrote:ThomZajac wrote:steve manning wrote:Thom,I didn't mean to suggest all of it was valid, mainly the point about the unattended casket theory of Lifton. I was in too much of a hurry myself and didn't take the time to trim the fat. Don't even bother dealing with the rest of it; but thanks for ...

Thom,I didn't mean to suggest all of it was valid, mainly the point about the unattended casket theory of Lifton. I was in too much of a hurry myself and didn't take the time to trim the fat. Don't even bother dealing with the rest of it; but thanks for reading it all anyway.Sorry for any confusionS...

Dealey Joe wrote:Well i don't really know where it came from or if it did.The throat wound looks like a bullet hole for sure. it could have been bullet fragmentts, glass or a peice of the car.Gill has that bullet bouncing around quite a bit.you know strange things that are not readily explainable do...

Just trying to bring another voice on the Lifton phenomenon. Here is a critique of Best Evidence and here is the link it came from:http://mcadams.posc.mu.edu/wrone.htm[Lapses such as support of Zapruder film alteration theories] on Lifton’s part are far too frequent. Other examples can be found in B...

ThomZajac wrote:Good discussion, Steve, thanks.You wrote-"We might start another thread about Lifton, but suffice it to say, my confidence in his work has been shaken...especially the basis of his reasoning for claiming the casket was left unattended in Air Force One, which supposedly left enou...